Manufacturing Consulting From Someone Who Has Run the Machine
Manufacturing consulting from Manufacturing Solutions Group starts on your floor, not in a slide deck. We work with owner-run shops of roughly 10 to 200 people, job shops and contract manufacturers included, where the owner is still the scheduler, the quoter and the last set of eyes before a part ships.
Our founder came up as a millwright, supervised crews through plant overhauls, and built and ran a precision manufacturing group before MSG. That is the difference between a manufacturing consultant who has studied your problem and one who has had it.
Three things people mean by "manufacturing consultant," and which one your shop needs
The phrase covers three different animals, and buyers get burned by calling the wrong one. A lean manufacturing consultant coaches your people through value stream maps and kaizen events. An ERP or Industry 4.0 implementer sells and configures software. A strategy firm studies the business and writes a plan for the board. Each tends to see every problem as the one it sells. The fourth option is where we sit: an operator-led firm that fixes the process first and only then decides whether software or a machine is worth buying.
| Who you called | What they fix | What you hold at the end | Built for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lean coach | Waste and flow, through events and training | Trained people, visual boards, a binder | Stable-volume plants with a leadership team to sustain it |
| ERP or MES implementer | Data and reporting inside one software product | A configured system and a go-live | Companies whose process already works and needs a system of record |
| Strategy firm | Markets, footprint, cost structure, acquisitions | A deck and a roadmap | Multi-plant groups and owners preparing a sale |
| Operator-led firm (MSG) | The schedule, the quote, the changeover and the handoffs that make orders late | A working process your supervisors run, with the scorecard that proves it | One plant, owner-run, needs it fixed rather than studied |
- Who you called
- Lean coach
- What they fix
- Waste and flow, through events and training
- What you hold at the end
- Trained people, visual boards, a binder
- Built for
- Stable-volume plants with a leadership team to sustain it
- Who you called
- ERP or MES implementer
- What they fix
- Data and reporting inside one software product
- What you hold at the end
- A configured system and a go-live
- Built for
- Companies whose process already works and needs a system of record
- Who you called
- Strategy firm
- What they fix
- Markets, footprint, cost structure, acquisitions
- What you hold at the end
- A deck and a roadmap
- Built for
- Multi-plant groups and owners preparing a sale
- Who you called
- Operator-led firm (MSG)
- What they fix
- The schedule, the quote, the changeover and the handoffs that make orders late
- What you hold at the end
- A working process your supervisors run, with the scorecard that proves it
- Built for
- One plant, owner-run, needs it fixed rather than studied
The problems that bring a 10 to 200 person manufacturer to us
Owners rarely call about lean or process improvement by name. They call because something on the floor has gone from annoying to expensive. These are the six we hear most.
What it sounds like when you call
- Late orders. On-time delivery drifts from the high nineties to the seventies and a good customer starts asking for weekly status calls. Left alone, that customer dual-sources you.
- Quotes that miss. The estimate says six hours, the job takes eleven, and nobody compares the two until the margin report lands. Left alone, revenue grows while profit shrinks.
- Changeovers that eat a shift. The fixture is somewhere, the program is on a thumb drive, the first article waits on one inspector. Left alone, you buy a second machine to get capacity you already own.
- Scrap and rework nobody logs. Parts get remade quietly because logging them feels like blame, so the same defect returns every quarter.
- The ERP or MES you work around. Routers are in the system but the real schedule is a whiteboard and a group text. You pay for a system of record that records nothing.
- The schedule in one person's head. One supervisor knows which jobs can slip, and the plant runs on that memory until that person takes a vacation.
Job shops and contract manufacturers: why high mix changes the playbook
Most of what gets written about manufacturing improvement assumes a line that runs the same part every day. A job shop or contract manufacturer runs hundreds of part numbers in small lots, and the rules change. Takt time means little when the mix changes by the hour. What matters is how work queues at each machine, how parts group into families that share setups, and how one expedite reorders the week.
So we group parts into families by routing and setup so changeovers chain instead of collide. We make every queue visible so the owner can see where the week is stuck without walking the floor. We set priority rules so an expedite moves one job, not every job. And we tie quoting to the hours each family actually consumes, because the quote is where a job shop wins or loses money before the material arrives.
The first week on your floor: what we walk, what we pull, what we count
The engagement opens with a week on site. We walk every cell on every shift, because second shift runs a different plant than first and the owner usually only sees one of them. We ask everyone who touches an order the same question: where does your work wait?
Then we pull the data that already exists, whether or not anyone reads it: the open order list, the late list, ninety days of quotes next to the hours charged against them, the scrap tickets or the absence of them, and the ERP's audit trail to see which screens get used. What the system cannot tell us, we count by hand: changeover minutes on the constraint machine, work in process at each queue, and how many times an order gets touched between the office and the dock.
On day five the owner gets a one-page findings sheet: the constraint, the three handoffs that cause most of the lateness, the quote-to-actual gap by part family, and the one thing we would fix first. If the plant needs training or a grant program more than it needs us, that goes on the page too.
Fix the schedule before you buy the software
Every software vendor sells the tool as the fix, and every machine dealer sells capacity as the fix. Sometimes they are right. More often a shop buys a scheduling system to fix a discipline it never had, or a second machine to fix changeovers it never measured. The new thing inherits the old habits, and six months later the whiteboard is back.
Three tells say the software is premature: the schedule changes daily by phone call rather than by rule, the quote and the router disagree about how a part is made, and the last purchase was made to fix a people problem. We fix the rules, the router and the handoffs first and run them for a few weeks. Only then do we say whether the system you own can carry the process or a purchase is now worth making. We hold no reseller agreement with anyone.
The scorecard you keep: manufacturing process improvement you can read on a whiteboard
A promise without a baseline is a sales pitch. Before we change anything we measure the plant the way it runs today, and the same seven numbers become the scorecard your supervisors read after we leave.
| Metric | How we baseline it | How often it is read |
|---|---|---|
| On-time delivery | Ship date against promise date, every order, last 90 days | Weekly |
| Lead time by part family | Order entry to ship, by routing family | Weekly |
| Scrap and rework rate | Remakes and rework hours against parts produced, counted even when unlogged | Weekly |
| Changeover minutes | Last good part to first good part on the constraint machine, timed on the floor | Each changeover in the pilot, then weekly |
| Quote-to-actual variance | Estimated hours against charged hours, by family | Monthly |
| Throughput per labor hour | Shipped standard hours against paid hours | Monthly |
| Cash in WIP | Material and labor in open orders, counted at each queue | Monthly |
- Metric
- On-time delivery
- How we baseline it
- Ship date against promise date, every order, last 90 days
- How often it is read
- Weekly
- Metric
- Lead time by part family
- How we baseline it
- Order entry to ship, by routing family
- How often it is read
- Weekly
- Metric
- Scrap and rework rate
- How we baseline it
- Remakes and rework hours against parts produced, counted even when unlogged
- How often it is read
- Weekly
- Metric
- Changeover minutes
- How we baseline it
- Last good part to first good part on the constraint machine, timed on the floor
- How often it is read
- Each changeover in the pilot, then weekly
- Metric
- Quote-to-actual variance
- How we baseline it
- Estimated hours against charged hours, by family
- How often it is read
- Monthly
- Metric
- Throughput per labor hour
- How we baseline it
- Shipped standard hours against paid hours
- How often it is read
- Monthly
- Metric
- Cash in WIP
- How we baseline it
- Material and labor in open orders, counted at each queue
- How often it is read
- Monthly
What it costs to keep running without help
We get called in after one of five things has already happened, each a version of the same mistake: treating the symptom with a purchase or an event instead of fixing the process that produces it.
The kaizen event that faded in ninety days because nobody owned the new standard. The ERP go-live that put the shop back on spreadsheets because the routers were wrong going in. The machine bought to fix a scheduling problem, now at sixty percent utilization. The lean binder mapping a plant that no longer runs that way. The supervisor who retired with the schedule in his head. None failed because the owner was careless. The fix was aimed at the wrong layer.
How an engagement runs on a plant floor
Four phases, with the hours your people give stated up front, because that is the real cost of the work. Most one-plant engagements finish inside eight to ten weeks. One cell or one product family can be faster.
Phases, and what they ask of your people
- Assess, about one week. The floor walk, the data pull and the findings sheet. Owner: about two hours a day that week. Supervisors: an hour each for interviews.
- Pilot, three to four weeks. One cell or one product family gets the new scheduling rules, family grouping, changeover standard and scorecard. Owner: two hours a week. Each supervisor in the pilot area: three hours a week. One operator per cell joins a ten-minute daily stand-up.
- Standardize, two to three weeks. What worked becomes the written standard, routers get corrected, the scorecard moves to the whiteboard, the ERP changes only where it must. Supervisor time drops to an hour a week.
- Hand over, one to two weeks. Your supervisors run it while we watch, we fix what breaks, and we leave a short playbook plus a thirty-day check-in. Then the plant owns it.
What moves the fee on a plant engagement
We quote two ways: a fixed-scope pilot for one cell or one product family, or a phased plant rollout where each phase is priced before it starts. No retainer, no subscription. The fee moves with five things: plants and shifts in scope, whether the data exists or has to be collected by hand, one cell or the whole floor, days on site versus remote, and whether software selection or integration is included. A one-shift job shop with a working ERP is the small end; a two-shift plant with no usable data is the large end. We tell you which end you are on after the first week, in writing.
Your MEP center, the big manufacturing consulting firms, or us: an honest fit guide
Three kinds of help exist for a manufacturer, and we would rather tell you which fits than win work that does not. Your state Manufacturing Extension Partnership center, which in Texas is TMAC, is the right call for training programs, grant-assisted projects, ISO preparation and low-cost assessments. The national manufacturing consulting firms are the right call for a multi-plant network, a merger integration, or a capital program deciding which plants to keep.
An operator-led firm is the right call when you have one plant, you run it yourself, and you need the schedule, the quote and the changeover fixed rather than studied. That is us. Two limits: we do not do ISO registrar work, and we do not staff your plant. We fix how it runs and leave it with the people who run it.
From millwright to the owner's side of the table
Manufacturing Solutions Group is run by people who have held the wrench. Karl Gillihan spent years as a millwright and projects lead on turbine decks and refinery floors at ExxonMobil, XTO Energy and Siemens Energy, where he supervised millwright crews and held nuclear clearance. He then founded and ran a precision manufacturing group building engineered parts for oil and gas and energy customers, including Siemens Energy. He has missed a ship date and quoted a part wrong with his own money on the line. Today he runs MSG and MfgBase from Texas. Roger Pemberton, our Operations Director, owns delivery on every engagement. The person on this page is the person who shows up at your plant.

Karl Gillihan
President
Founder and President of MSG. He came up as a rotating equipment specialist in the energy industry and now runs MFGBase, LocalAISource, and ServiceStorm.
About Karl GillihanFrequently asked
What does manufacturing consulting from MSG actually cover?
Scheduling and priority rules, quoting against actual hours, changeover reduction, scrap and rework tracking, office-to-floor handoffs, and whether the ERP or MES you own can carry the process. One plant at a time, mostly on site, left with your supervisors running it.
How much does manufacturing consulting cost?
A fixed-scope pilot for one cell or product family, or a phased plant rollout priced phase by phase. The fee moves with plants and shifts in scope, whether usable data exists, cell versus whole floor, on-site days, and whether software selection is included. You get a written number after the first week on your floor.
How long does an engagement take?
Most one-plant engagements finish inside eight to ten weeks: about a week to assess, three to four to pilot, two to three to standardize, one to two to hand over. One cell or one family runs shorter.
What is the difference between a lean manufacturing consultant and an ERP consultant?
A lean manufacturing consultant coaches flow and waste through events and training. An ERP consultant configures software to a go-live. Neither owns whether your orders ship on time. We fix the schedule, the quote and the changeover first, then say whether the software you have can carry it.
Is my shop too small to hire a manufacturing consultant?
Not if you have a floor, a schedule and late orders. Our typical client runs 10 to 200 people. Below that, a pilot on one machine or one family is usually the right size, and we will say so if even that is more than you need.
Should I use my state MEP center or a private manufacturing consulting firm?
Your MEP center, which in Texas is TMAC, for training, grants, ISO preparation and low-cost assessments. A national firm for multi-plant, merger or capital questions. An operator-led firm like ours when it is one plant, you run it, and you need it fixed rather than studied.
Do you work with job shops and contract manufacturers?
Yes, and they are most of what we see. High mix changes the playbook: part families, queue visibility, priority rules for expedites, and quoting tied to the hours each family really consumes.
Can you help if our ERP or MES is installed but nobody uses it?
That is one of the most common reasons we get called. Usually the routers are wrong, the schedule rules were never written down, or the system was bought to fix a people problem. We fix those first and reconfigure the system only where it has to change. Replacing it is the last option.
How do we measure whether manufacturing process improvement worked?
Against the baseline taken before anything changes: on-time delivery, lead time by family, scrap and rework rate, changeover minutes, quote-to-actual variance, throughput per labor hour and cash in WIP. The same seven numbers stay on your whiteboard after we leave.
Where do you work, and do you travel?
We are based in Southeast Texas and our clients are spread across the United States. Assessment and pilot weeks are on site at your plant, in any state. Standardize and hand-over mix on-site days with remote work. Travel is scoped into the proposal, not billed as a surprise.
Send us your late list and last month's quotes
We will tell you in writing what we would fix first, and whether it is a job for us, your MEP center, or nobody yet.